Their are many different types of rotary or reciprocating type
positive displacement pumps. Here is a comparison of each of the
following below.
|
ADVANTAGES
|
DISADVANTAGES
|
Internal Gear Pumps
(with crescent)
|
·
Only two moving parts
·
Only one stuffing box
·
Positive suction, non-pulsating discharge
·
Ideal for high viscosity liquids
·
Constant and even discharge regardless of
various pressure conditions
·
Available with built in safety relief valve
·
Can operate equally well in either direction
·
Can be made to operate with one direction of
flow with either rotation
·
Low NPSH required
·
Easy to maintain
|
·
Low speeds usually required
·
Medium pressure limitations
·
One bearing runs in product pumped
·
Overhung load on shaft bearing
|
External Gear Pumps
(Spur, helical, herringbone)
|
·
High Speed
·
Medium pressure
·
No overhung bearing loads
·
Relatively quiet
·
Design lends itself to use of a wide variety of
materials
|
·
Four bushings in liquid area
·
Four stuffing boxes
·
No solids allowed
|
Multiple Screw Pumps
(Two or three)
|
·
High speed
·
High pressures
·
Quiet
·
Sometimes considered as an “industry standard”
fuel pump
·
Good efficiency
·
Medium high capacity
|
·
No solids allowed
·
Expensive
·
Not good for very thin liquids
·
Two-screw pumps require timing gears
|
Single Screw Pumps
(Progressive cavity)
|
·
High solids allowed
·
Dry materials
·
High viscosity
·
Versatile (Same pump without changing clearance
can be used with such liquids as water, wine and syrup)
·
Good for sludge or slurry
|
·
Cannot run dry
·
Not for high temperatures (Stator swells)
·
Hard to maintain
·
Expensive parts
·
More space required
·
Stuffing box exposed to vacuum
|
Sliding Vane Pumps
(Unbalanced)
|
·
Medium capacity
·
Medium speed
·
Thin liquids
·
Sometimes preferred for solvents, LPG
·
Can be made to provide variable capacity
·
Can run dry for short periods
|
·
Most have two stuffing boxes
·
Not best for viscous liquids
·
Pressure medium
|
Sliding Vane Pumps
(Balanced)
|
·
Medium capacity
·
Medium speed
·
Thin liquids
·
Balanced radial bearing loads
·
One seal or stuffing box
·
Can run dry for short periods
·
Develops good vacuum
|
·
Complex casing
·
Not suitable for high viscosity
·
Not good with abrasives
|
Flexible Vane Pumps
(Flexible fingers on vanes)
|
·
Handle some solids
·
High vacuum
·
Relatively inexpensive
|
·
Low discharge pressure
·
Cannot run dry
·
Low temperatures only
·
Liquid must be compatible with elastomer in
rotor
|
Internal Gear Pumps
(With crescent)
|
·
Easiest to clean
·
Good on high viscosity
·
Better suction than lobe type
·
No timing gears required
·
Smaller space
·
Can run dry for short periods
·
Can be repaired in field
|
·
Will crush solids
·
Suction not as good as flexible vane
·
Bushing in product
|
Lobe Pumps
(Single, multiple and
circumferential piston)
|
·
Pass medium solids
·
Rates high acceptance
·
Little galling possibility
|
·
Timing gears required
·
More space required
·
Factory service required
·
Requires two seals
|
External Vane Pumps
|
·
Pass large solids
·
Little galling possibility
·
Simple
|
·
Expensive
·
Low rate of field acceptance
·
Low speed
|
Flexible Vane Pumps
(Flexible fingers on vanes)
|
·
Pass medium solids
·
High vacuum
·
Relatively inexpensive
·
Easy field maintenance
|
·
Low discharge pressure
·
Cannot run dry
·
Low temperature only
|